When holiday fanatic Addie makes a Christmas wish for her next door neighbor Sam to fall in love with her, she's not expecting anything to happen, and she definitely isn't expecting the wish to go awry and cause her other neighbor, Pete to fall in love instead. When Pete's romantic gestures grow more and more over-the-top, Addie recruits Sam to help. With Sam's assistance, can Addie break the spell by Christmas? Or will she spend the rest of her life dealing with a love-lorn Pete?